Dontreader

Salut!

Salut! Je suis Dontreader. Dontreader (discuter) 26 mars 2015 à 07:17 (CET)

Redhead Express

Hi, concerning the Redhead Express I think adding them to the list of personalities from Palmer is fine. I deleted your link in the bluegrass page because they are not what you could call a famous or influent band in the world of bluegrass. Actually, I'm not too worried about the article being an "orphan", but I do wonder whether this article should be on this WP at all. Given the sources mentioned in the article and our criteria, I'd say no. The band might be somewhat important locally (and I'm sure they're very good ), but it is far from having international recognition --or even national for that matter. Regards, --Frédéric-FR (discuter) 3 août 2016 à 12:15 (CEST)

Hi Frédéric-FR (d · c · b), thank you very much. Yes, the Redhead Express band does not meet the criteria for musical groups (at least not on the French Wikipedia, although on the English Wikipedia they do), but I think you would agree that they meet the WP:CGN criteria because they have received significant coverage in reliable independent sources, and the sources do not have to be in French, as you know. I created the article on the English Wikipedia, and then someone took small parts of that article to make the French article. Please read the article in English. There is lots of coverage and the sources are good (many newspapers, some local TV shows, etc.). My French is horrible (I understood the page you showed me, but I cannot write in French), so I cannot add the information from the English version, but maybe you could if you have time. Then the article would look notable here, je pense! Many thanks again for your reply, and please check out their two most recent videos on YouTube... fantastique! Dontreader (discuter) 3 août 2016 à 12:45 (CEST)