Discussion modèle:Palette Localités abandonnées lors de l'exode palestinien de 1948
Dernier commentaire : il y a 4 ans par Kimdime dans le sujet Hi
Autres discussions [liste]
- Admissibilité
- Neutralité
- Droit d'auteur
- Article de qualité
- Bon article
- Lumière sur
- À faire
- Archives
- Commons
Hi modifier
Utilisateur:Kimdime, hi, you asked me some places were included, and not the others: it is all down to history. This started as a template over the villages mentioned in Walid Khalidi's: "All that remain"; then other (bigger cities) were included. Lydda and Ramla were included, as their depopulation was very well covered (see Exode palestinien de Lydda et Ramle), al-Majdal was not included, as that is included in Ashkelon. However, I don't have any good answer to why Safed, (or for that matter, Beit She'an, or Tiberias) are not included; perhaps because they were "mixed" places, ie not places overwhelmingly Palestinian, Huldra (discuter) 12 juin 2019 à 22:50 (CEST)
- Hi Huldra, thanks for the explanation, Wikipedia is a work in progress anyway. I think that ultimately it would be interesting to add the aforementioned places, but for the time being, I'm busy enough with the translations :). --Kimdime (discuter) 13 juin 2019 à 14:16 (CEST)