Discussion:Brasilândia/Archive Commons
Fichier proposé à la suppression sur Commons
modifier
Le fichier File:Brasão Brasilândia MS2.jpg utilisé sur cet article a été proposé à la suppression sur Commons. Le motif invoqué est : « Unclear copyright status, per previous DRs. {{t|PD-self}} licensed uploads regarding official symbols (coat of arms / brasão + flag / bandeira) of Brazilian municipalities, based on arguments derived from Brazilian trademark law (Lei de Propriedade Industrial Brasileira 9.279) which does not apply (see also the long-term misunderstanding reflected in c:Commons:Deletion requests/Template:PD-BrazilGov 2, when template was updated). Btw, art. 191 from this law (used as reference by uploader) says "DOS CRIMES COMETIDOS POR MEIO DE MARCA, TÍTULO DE ESTABELECIMENTO E SINAL DE PROPAGANDA: Reproduzir ou imitar, de modo que possa induzir em erro ou confusão, armas, brasões ou distintivos oficiais nacionais, estrangeiros ou internacionais, sem a necessária autorização, no todo ou em parte, em marca, título de estabelecimento, nome comercial, insígnia ou sinal de propaganda, ou usar essas reproduções ou imitações com fins econômicos." = [more or less] It is prohibited to use coats of arms and other distinctive [inter]national symbols in trademarks, establishment titles , commercial names, advertising (...) or use this reproductions/imitations for economic [commercial] purposes. They may be in public domain only via {{t|PD-BrazilGov}} = "published or commissioned by a Brazilian government (federal, state, or municipal) prior to 1983" or by other means (I ignored obvious PD-shape/PD-whatever cases like this one) but relevant info — per c:COM:EVID — must be provided. In detail, we need always the date of the related municipal law to determine the PD-status — which is not given (btw, not given for almost all coats of arms and flags of Brazilian municipalities, however they are currently licensed) All coats of arms and flags of Brazilian municipalities are established individually by municipal law (mostly some years after official federal constitution, often citing the original designers), as also further redesigns of the symbols which [often] are completely different to the historic ones (see also this case, where a Brazilian municipality created his official symbols only 81 years after emancipation: in 2014). Brazilian coats of arms and flags created after 1982 are [if above c:COM:TOO) protected 70 pma or (if anonymous or pseudonymous works) +70 years from the first publication. See also: http://jus.com.br/artigos/14982/orgaos-publicos-dominio-publico-e-licencas-publicas. A quick run reveals also that, even trying to apply {{t|PD-BrazilGov}}, fails for (examples): Obs.: the year of emanicpation is the year of the related federal law, deciding to create the municipality. The official installation of the municipality occurs only year(s) later. So, even municipalities established before 1983 may have needed several years to create and adopt their official symbols by own municipal legislation. *File:Bandeira Tamandaré PE.jpg --> emancipated only in 1995 *File:Brasão Tamandaré PE.jpg --> emancipated only in 1995 *File:Brasão Domiciliar Recursolândia TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1989 *File:Brasão Domiciliar Sítio Novo do Tocantins TO.jpg --> created by law only in 1989 *File:Brasão Domiciliar Santa Rita do Tocantins TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1994 *File:Brasão Domiciliar São Miguel do Tocantins TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1991 *File:Bandeira Municipal São Bento do Tocantins TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1993 *File:Brasão Domiciliar São Bento do Tocantins TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1993 *File:Bandeira Municipal Santa Terezinha do Tocantins TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1993 *File:Bandeira Municipal Santa Tereza do Tocantins TO.JPG --> emancipated only in 1988 *File:Brasão Domiciliar Aliança do Tocantins TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1988 *File:Brasão Domiciliar Aguiarnópolis TO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1988 *File:Brasão Acrelândia AC.jpg --> emancipated only in 1988 *File:Brasão Rio Crespo RO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1992 *File:Brasão Quixabeira BA.png --> emancipated only in 1989 *File:Bandeira Quixabeira BA.png --> emancipated only in 1989 *File:Brasão Ponto Novo BA.jpg --> emancipated only in 1989 *File:Brasão Cabaceiras do Paraguaçu BA.jpg --> emancipated only in 1989 *File:Bandeira Cabaceiras do Paraguaçu BA.jpg --> emancipated only in 1989 *File:Brasão Aricanduva MG.png --> emancipated only in 1995 *File:Brasão de Chapadão Céu GO.png --> emancipated only in 1991 *File:Bandeira Chapadão Céu GO.png --> emancipated only in 1991 *File:Brasão Sapezal MT.png --> emancipated only in 1994 *File:Brasão Primavera do Leste MT.png --> emancipated only in 1986 *File:Bandeira Primavera do Leste MT.png --> emancipated only in 1986 *File:Brasão Serrano do Maranhão.jpg --> emancipated only in 1997 *File:Bandeira Serrano do Maranhão.jpg --> emancipated only in 1997 *File:Brasão Água Fria de Góias.png --> emancipated only in 1987 *File:Bandeira Água Fria de Góias GO.png --> emancipated only in 1987 *File:Brasão de Campo Limpo de Góias GO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1997 *File:Bandeira de Campo Limpo de Góias GO.jpg --> emancipated only in 1997 * etc. etc. etc. For the others: I don't know (detailed information about the origin of these symbols are mostly not available online or only hardly to find) and for the uploader {{u|Jocelio}}: it did not matter... ---- ». Vous pouvez exprimer votre avis sur cette demande de suppression sur la sous-page associée : lien (voir en particulier les règles de Commons vis-à-vis des licences).
Si vous avez les droits sur ce fichier et voulez donner l'autorisation de le publier sous une licence compatible, suivez ces instructions. Pour connaître la liste complète de fichiers utilisés sur Wikipédia actuellement en procédure de suppression sur Commons, consultez la liste située ici.
Message déposé par NaggoBot (discuter) le 6 mars 2016 à 21:25 (CET)